A couple of days ago I saw that Oliver had put up a new post, entitled "Gender". Ooh, that'll be interesting, I thought; Olly usually has something worthwhile to say, and gender is a pretty interesting issue.
Unfortunately, I had a few issues with some of what he'd written, so here's a response.
It boils down to three five
things:
Number
zero is binary language. Women and men are not the only genders in human
society. There is no such thing as “the other or our own gender”, because gender
is not a binary system.
Number
one is basically just a quibble about you language, although... well.
Basically, you have a post on two different things. Half of it is about gender,
and half of it's about gender; the former animal, the latter human. And those
are really different things.
When
'gender' is used in reference to animals, you're basically talking sex.
Genitals. Biology.
But
when you talk about humans, you're talking about an advanced social construct
that affects far more than just reproduction; you're talking about the idea of
gender roles, of patriarchy and wage disparity and suffrage and a whole host of
issues that relate to how society treats men, women, and people of other
genders.
There's
nothing wrong, per se, with a post that talks about gender and gender. But it's
important not to conflate the two, because they're very different. (That's also
one of the mistakes/lies that Aurini uses, the assumption/assertion that humans
are simply biological machines. Even wolves have social dynamics, and if you
ignore those you don't get a full picture of how wolves - or people - work)
Point
two is your, well, treating genders en bloc. You say in your anecdote that you
were the ‘male-concrete’ your friend needed; has it occurred to you that you
may just have been, well, concrete? Providing stability and support, of
whatever kind, is not an exclusively male attribute; nor is reacting to certain
types of stress in certain ways an exclusively non-male one. These are personal
relationships between two people, reactions and responses from individuals. You're human beings, not
stand-ins for your respective genders.
The
third is your argument against treating genders en bloc. In fact, your whole ‘coda’,
the more I read it, is elitist, individualistic, explicitly misogynistic and – by
extension of your argument – racist, ableist, and in general terms, shit. If
you still identify with the left, you should be deeply ashamed of it.
Don’t
worry; I won’t call you those names without explaining. And bear with me,
because this is a long one. Where to start, though?
OK:
why are women proportionally under-represented in television?
If everyone is “simply
[being] the best one can”, and women are equal to men (I’ll leave minority
gender identities out of this for now, to keep it relatively simple, but that's not to say they don't exist, or that they're not equal), then women and men would have equal opportunity to
be on television; you’d therefore expect that television would have a ratio of
women to men approximately the same as that in the general population.
But
that’s not the case. Something – some factor – means that fewer women are going
on television. Possibility one: women and men have equal opportunity, but fewer
women choose to take it. That seems fairly unlikely, especially as a pattern
that crops up for years and years in lots and lots of places.*
Possibility two: women and men are, fundamentally, not equal. If you’re willing to accept this explanation, then you’re flying in the face of the evidence, and you’re also a disgusting human being. (It does seem to be the option that Aurini seems to be working from, incidentally…)
Possibility two: women and men are, fundamentally, not equal. If you’re willing to accept this explanation, then you’re flying in the face of the evidence, and you’re also a disgusting human being. (It does seem to be the option that Aurini seems to be working from, incidentally…)
Possibility
three: there’s an additional factor that means women have a lesser opportunity
to go into television. Maybe traditional gender roles mean they’re expected to
stay at home and look after the kids; maybe the hiring department is biased
against women; maybe one of a million ways in which patriarchy manifests.
What
this means, the myriad of subtle and not-so-subtle ways in which a patriarchal
society limits the opportunities of women, is that men – including you and me –
have something called privilege.
INTERMISSION:
Privilege 101
The
basic idea behind privilege is that it’s the things that a member of a privileged/oppressive group has that a member of an oppressed group doesn’t. There are two
basic forms:
- There’re the basic human rights that everyone should have, but which are only extended to the oppressive group. For example, when men could vote but women couldn’t, that was male privilege; only men had a basic human right that everybody should have had.
- Then there’s the specific oppression that isn’t faced by members of the oppressing group. In this case, it’s things that shouldn’t happen to anybody, but which do happen (or happen far more often) to people in the oppressed group. White people, for example, don’t usually have to fear being beaten up by the police for little or no reason, in contrast to many people of colour (PoC)
The
male privilege checklist at http://www.amptoons.com/blog/the-male-privilege-checklist/
is worth checking out for more explanation and examples, and other checklists
are very worth reading.
There's a few important principles to remember about privilege:
There's a few important principles to remember about privilege:
- If you're part of a privileged group, then you have privilege.
- You might not be aware of it, but it still exists. Just because you don't notice it doesn't mean it's not there - and indeed, not being aware that some people don't have it as good as you do is a form of privilege in and of itself.
- You might have a really shitty life, but you still have privilege, because you're better off than you would be if you weren't in that group. A woman might be wary of going to the police after being sexually assaulted; a woman who is also trans* has even more reason to be wary of going to the police.
- Privilege stacks. As someone who is both white and male, I have white privilege and male privilege. Equally, oppression stacks- that's called intersectionality, and it means that someone who is, for example, both a PoC and female is going to suffer because of both of those things. The oppression certainly adds, and in some cases it multiplies.
Firstly, we can be aware of it. Familiarise yourself with some of the most common examples; the checklists are great for that. Be aware that you have and show privilege, and check it- both in the sense of noticing it, and trying to limit it.
More importantly, really, in the long run, we can campaign and destroy the social institutions that create and reinforce privilege and oppression. But that's a post for another day.
INTERMISSION OVER
Where were we? Oh yes. Privilege.
In the television industry, as with most of our society, there's a strong and well-established patriarchy - domination by men. It's been challenged a bit in recent decades, and there've undoubtedly been improvements, but there's still social attitudes and biases that mean that women have a lot fewer opportunities. So the reason there are fewer women in television? It's not because women aren't "simply [being] the best [they] can"; it's because their opportunities are limited.
*(Side note: if Possibility One is true in some specific cases, there's a good chance that it's because of internalised misogyny; women being taught by society that, for whatever reason, they can't/shouldn't go into television. And that's equally wrong)
SO
Women are proportionally under-represented in television because of the patriarchy. How can we stop this?
Smashing the patriarchy is the only long-term solution. Changing society so that men are no longer privileged, and more likely to get into television, is a good goal, but it's a long way off. In the mean time - in the short term - it's important to take measures that address the outcome (fewer women in TV) even if they don't address the causes (biased hiring practices, for example).
For one thing, that kind of scheme is useful as a step towards breaking down the patriarchy; showing women, and men, that women can be on TV as something more than decoration should mean that future generations of hiring executives won't be as biased against women, that little girls growing up now feel they have an equal chance of making it onto TV.
It doesn't tip the balance against men; it just evens it out. At the moment, we have privilege, and women have oppression, and that's unequal, because men have a greater opportunity than women. With an 'affirmative action' policy, or whatever you want to call it, we still have privilege and women have affirmative action; if it's done right, the opportunity should be equal, and the outcome will be a society where, assuming everyone "simply [does] the best [they] can", then they have equal opportunity.
The argument against 'constucted' equality is still an argument against equality. It's an argument that seeks to preserve the undeserved privilege that society gives to men, and other privileged groups. We don't have any right to that advantage, and if we believe in equality - of outcome or opportunity - we should willingly disavow that privilege and support measures that seek to end it.
The position you adopt suggests that either society is fine as it is - which must mean that women are inferior - or that society is flawed, but because changing it might disadvantage you, it shouldn't be changed. The former is misogynistic, the latter is barbarically elitist and individualistic. And that's why I say you're wrong.
Of course, I've used women as the example of an oppressed group throughout; the same arguments can be made about people of colour, disabled people, LGBTQ people, or any other oppressed group.)
Thanks for the reply, Tim.
ReplyDeleteHere is my post for those who're interested: http://olivermeredithcox.wordpress.com/2013/01/24/gender/
Binary Gender
Now this is a very tough one, to what extent is, or can we regard, humanity as having two genders? Of course, and as is the case with most things, both the physical and psychological attributes of gender occur on a spectrum; but, what is the most convenient and useful way in which we can talk about the subject? Hilary Putnam is useful here, see his 'Twin Earth' experiment; before DNA people would have defined gender morphologically, but then we started finding people who're XY but female morphologically, for example. In this sense, ideas of gender are always going to be tough. However, I think that one useful way (of many) in which we can run our discourse, is to look at a graph of morphology (score out of 100, with 100 possessing particularly 'female' characteristics and 0 possessing particularly 'male' ones) one will find a double bell-curve, I propose that we call each peak a gender. It makes sense in certain discourses to consider gender in this manner, two basic roles and morphologies and variety among them this exists in many of nature (not all of course). One can make this graph using psychology, also.
Of course, people can exist on any point of the axis, and some people exist right in the middle. I speak from a position of privilege, as you note, in that I fit nicely into the male gender; but many people don't. I have only a little idea of what it's like for these individuals, my response is that we should create a society in which people are knowledgeable and open about such matters. Foremost, I am not being disrespectful by saying that, within this discourse, it is useful to refer to gender as binary, I'm just making an observation. Foremost, when I observe his 'is' I am not implying anything normative
Social Gender
You're annoyed that I don't distinguish social gender and biological gender, what could be the origin of our social genders, if not our biology? The brain is an organ in the same way as the genitals are.
However, are all the differences between men and women in society natural? Of course not, I would move that a large part of the exemption of women from suffrage was due to pseudo-science.
How should we treat the differences which arise naturally due to gender? Wage-disparity, in some degree, is the economic result of the fact that woman have to take time off to have children; inasmuch we want our species to continue we need to procreate, wage-disparity on this grounds is natural but immoral.
To some extent, when a family breaks out the Guardian weekend, men read the main paper and women read the magazine and family; as long as people are free to choose, I think that this is something which is natural, but with which we can live.
Concrete Bloc
The whole point of my article was to discuss gender, if I wrote an article about going to be supportive for my friend I would have expressed it without referring to gender; inasmuch as the article was about gender and the BBC programme, I cited our respective genders and how they affect our relationship.
Equality
ReplyDeleteGiven that we're talking about media and journalism, not biology or sociology; I move that we shouldn't use my double bell-curve distribution, or consider gender at all. My normative priority for a good media recruitment system is that it should seek the best individuals; by induction this means that it should not recruit according to gentlemen's club connections and should not send people away because of something which is not their ability as a journalist (such as their gender). That last sentence, one should note, is superfluous.
Broadcasters should not be concerned with the gender of their employees (unless the role is gender sensitive). If, through a fair system, one gender outweighs the other, then this is something we have to live with. We might find, when we create a fair system, that women outnumber men, and this would be fine.
I think that this is a fair summary of your argument:--
Men and women are equal.
Equal people, under fair conditions, should (this is not a moral 'should') have a stake in any organisation which reflects the percentage of their type in society.
Men and women want to do the same things to the same extent.
Therefore, if the BBC's gender ratio does not reflect that of society, an immoral process which makes women have less of a chance is underway.
I disagree with this narrative. Firstly, I don't think we should even try to pose or disprove the first premise, it's too difficult, to complicated; the same is true for the second premise, trying to determine these things almost takes us to the realm of chaos-theory.
Here's my argument:--
In areas of society such as employers and education centres, people should be judged as an individual.
Individuals should be treated fairly. (This is an axiom, I can't prove to you that people should have equal representation before the law, for example, all I can say is that most people get what they want when people are treated fairly.)
Therefore, if the BBC's gender ratio does not reflect that of society, we don't need to worry, unless premise 1 or 2 has been broken.
I think this is as far as our arguments can collide, in that our premises are so different.
You say that my argument means that I think that society is fine as it is, which certainly wasn't the content of my article.
'The way in which we can create a better media in Britain will be by giving all individuals access to the best education and training, by inspiring confidence in their own talents, and by creating a truly fair selection process. The actual percentage of women or men who appear on screen or on the radio is irrelevant, why should we care? One’s target should be, simply, to be the best one can.'
This means provision for creches, ramps for wheelchair users etc., but not quotas. I didn't say that society is fine, nor did I say that it isn't fine but that changes would hurt me. I hope that that addresses your points/clarifies my position.
Thanks for reading and thanks for your comment!
ReplyDeleteThis might be of interest: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uZhGuk6_04M&list=PLD63D4082262AFDD9
And this: http://olivermeredithcox.wordpress.com/2012/05/08/the-liberal-metropolitan-elite/