More detailed thoughts on the Occupy movement are one of the posts I've got planned for this blog, but the urgency of this situation is not lost on me, so here are a few comments on the eviction...
First off, what an absolute fucking disgrace; the bailiffs are making their attack in the middle of the night. Maybe they're rightfully embarrassed by their completely immoral attack on peaceful citizens exercising their democratic right to protest; it's hardly a surprise that they're hiding this brutal attack from the eyes of the British people.
More likely, though, is that they're attempting to strike when the protestors are at their weakest, in need of sleep and without the protection afforded by eyewitnesses. What surprises me is that it's this early; I was expecting to wake up one morning soon and find that this had happened overnight, at three or four in the morning.
Secondly, good grief is the BBC news coverage biased. It's not exactly unexpected from the state news channel, but the studio's really pressing the anti-Occupy line, the pessimism, defence of repression, and justification of the 'legality' of the eviction.
What's interesting is that their man on the ground (Jeremy something?) is surprisingly sympathetic. He's obviously spent some time in the camp, back when it was providing free education, free food and water, free shelter to the needy masses (more than the government or their banking buddies have ever managed), and he's clearly taken on board the Occupiers' message that this is not the end.
On the subject of BBC bias, it's striking how much time they give to the one person they were able to scrape up who complained about the Occupation, even when he's flat out lying about increase crime rates, reduced business, and hostility from the local community. Compare the several minutes that 'Mark' was given to the few sentences that most of the protestors who got to speak were given.
---------------------
This is one of the oldest continuous Occupations in the world; persisting from October 15th 2011 until February 28th 2012
In fact, it's that open space, and the potential that it has, that offers the best chance for OccupyLondon now. The tent city, the semi-permanent settlement was never the object of the occupation; the object was rather to maintain a presence, and that presence flourished through its use of a genuinely and directly democratic decision making process, the General Assembly system.
And General Assemblies can continue without tents; all they need are people. There's already talk of a General Assembly tomorrow.
One way of looking at this eviction, then, is an administrative setback, an inconvenience that will make organisation more difficult, but which will not limit the capacity of the Occupy Movement to practice its unique and immensely powerful version of democratic decision-making and protest.
---------------------
That issue of the 'legality' of the eviction is something else I'd like to pick up on. The very existence of bailiffs is a good example of how force and wealth are the real heart of the established system; these are people, authorised by 'law', to destroy and interfere with the private property of citizens engaged in the peaceful exercise of their right to free assembly. Isn't our law supposed to uphold our rights? Well, no; the law, especially when it's twisted by powerful and outright corrupt groups like the Corporation of the City of London, exists to serve the interests of the people who control it. Judges drawn from the upper classes, or tempted into the establishment by wealth and privilege, aren't terribly likely to give a fair hearing (literally) to a movement which, at its heart, challenges those structures of entrenched privilege.
The law is a malleable thing, and the people who twist it; the people who make the laws, the judges who interpret them, the powerful corporations and their lawyers who steamroll any opposition to their will; these are the people whom the law serves, and has done for centuries.
That's why the law can permit the existence of bailiffs; that's why the law, and the corrupt state that it serves, takes it upon itself to destroy rights rather than uphold them, when it is convenient for their clients.
I am reminded of a line from Roy Bailey's brilliant song about the Diggers, in reference to the ruling class; "They make the laws / to chain us well". The law is not a fountain of absolute morality, nor is it a reflection of the democratic will of the people, nor is it even a system by which fundamental rights are upheld. It is merely a system which serves the interests of the powerful elites that dominate our society.
Peaceful protest is all very well, but this is squatting on someone else's property without their permission or approval. The eviction would have been carried out at midnight because most people would have gone back to their homes,B&Bs or friends' sofas for the night. Commitment and passion, Phooey!
ReplyDeleteRegards
Geoff Theasby