So this post started out as a simple status update on Facebook, and then... it started growing. What follows is a fairly lengthy post about the face that British Quakers are sending a delegation to give a 'loyal address to the queen' as part of the jubilee celebrations, which I really don't agree with. Please forgive the length, and do share your thoughts and opinions.
First of all, the facts. Sometime soon, in March I believe, a group of twelve "Friends representing different parts of [Britain] yearly meeting" will give a 'loyal address' to the Queen at Buckingham Palace. This is part of the celebrations of the Queen's diamond jubilee, and BYM has been invited because it is a "Privileged Body". Apparently, something similar happened ten years ago for the golden jubilee. The loyal address will consist of a written address of about a page, and a spoken address of a couple of paragraphs.
At YFGM this weekend, we were told that YFGM had been invited to provide two of the twelve in the delegation. A few people (myself included) gave ministry based on opposition to the principle of a monarchy, and the lack of any positive impact from participating. Others spoke on the importance of speaking truth to power, and of the importance of YFGM being included in a BYM delegation. We didn't have a copy of the address that will be given (I believe it was to be drafted on the 17th Feb), but the clerk read out the spoken address that was given at the golden jubilee. (I can't find a copy of this anywhere, and I would be really grateful if somebody could point me to it) The meeting eventually accepted a minute that accepted the principle of sending two people, and at the end of the weekend two people were nominated for the role. I didn't recognise one of the names, but the other was somebody I'd considered nominating myself, someone who had given ministry opposing the monarchy and will hopefully represent young, republican Quakers quite well in the role.
So there's the facts. Why do I feel so strongly about the issue, and why, if the feeling of the meeting (both Sufferings and YFGM) was to participate, do I still feel that it was completely and utterly the wrong decision?
Monarchy and Equality
Let's begin with the monarchy.
I am a Quaker, and a card-carrying republican (literally: http://republic.org.uk/). As a Quaker and a socialist, I am wholly committed to the principle of equality, and working towards a more equal society. The monarchy is one of the most glaring examples of inequality in Britain, both historically and today.
To begin with, the principle of a monarch, somebody appointed by 'divine right' (in the context of an Established and historically repressive national Church) to rule over the people of this country runs entirely contrary to the notion of political equality. Perhaps worse, the fact of a monarchy with vast personal wealth, a fortune lavished upon them by the taxpayer, and claims to large parts of the British countryside (we'll ignore the Crown's alloidal claim for now) means that the monarchy is fundamentally contrary to the any ideas of social and economic equality.
The way I see it, then, is that to be a Quaker, and uphold a testimony to equality, is mutually exclusive with supporting or endorsing the monarchy. I'm not saying every Quaker should be a card-carrying Republican (though that'd be nice), since a) individual freedom of belief is also a pretty key part of Quakerism and b) there are lots of other really important issues for Quakers to focus their attention on. But I am saying that facilitating, endorsing, or simply acknowledging the legitimacy of the monarchy is contrary to the testimony to Equality.
That's just one of the objections to the monarchy (though it is probably the most important).
We also mustn't forget that the monarchy, and the Established Anglican church, has a lengthy history of
oppression, both of the British people in general, and of Quakers and
other minority religious groups in particular.
The monarch is the head of the Church of England, a religious denomination which about 1.9% of the population regularly participate in (three million attend a church service at least once a year, including Christmas and Easter services). And yet this Church is Established; it is legally our national church, and twenty-six of its highest clergy have a seat in the House of Lords, part of the legislature of the country.
Quakers are just one of the religious groups who suffered historically for their refusal to associate with the Church of England, being imprisoned, fined, abused and punished for their refusal to pay tithes to support the Established church, their recusancy from the Anglican church, and in general simply for desiring freedom of religion. The monarch, as the head of that church, is a symbol of that history of intolerance; and in a modern context, she is unable to act with the neutrality that a political figure should have in matters of religion.
With regard to the monarchy, then, Quakers should at best be neutral; ideally they would oppose it.
Speaking Truth to Power
The phrase "speaking truth to power", though it was only coined by American Friends in the fifties, is a pretty good description of what Quakers have been doing for several centuries. Perhaps the most prominent, and certainly the earliest, was the 1660 Declaration to the newly Restored king, Charles II, of what would become known as the Peace Testimony.
This, and the idea of speaking truth to power in general, got mentioned a couple of times at YFGM. The idea of speaking truth to power is basically that, since Quakers don't go in for converting people, all we can do to spread our ideas is to explain them peacefully to people, and hope that they take on board what we're saying; and if they're the people in power, help implement those ideas. It's a really good idea, and even if it isn't always immediately successful, it has a positive impact on the world, provoking thought and spreading understanding of our position.
The argument that got used in this context is that since speaking truth to power is a good thing, and a valuable part of Quakerism, and we've given addresses to the monarchy with that intention before, then taking part this time has to be a good thing.
My problems with this argument are threefold:
- Firstly, we're not speaking truth. Now, unfortunately, because I don't know the exact address that's going to be given, I can only base the following comments on the address given in 2002, and since I don't have a copy of that address I can only base my thoughts on what i can remember from what was read out at YFGM. That said, that address seemed to talk about Quaker work towards peace, mediation, social justice, etc. In other words, all good things that are in line with the Quaker message. What it didn't mention was our problem with the monarchy, with the fundamental inequality of monarchy. This seems like a major omission given a) the centrality of equality, alongside all those other issues, to Quakerism and b) the occasion; when better to speak truth about the monarchy than when addressing the monarch? So to talk about Quaker work without challenging the monarchy is lying by omission; as Quakers, with a testimony to truth and integrity, that's not really appropriate.
- Secondly, we're not speaking to power. Britain is, for all the faults and inappropriate inclusion of the monarchy, more or less a democracy now. Power rests in the hands of
the bankersParliament, and in particular the politicians of the two-and-a-half major parties. To speak truth to power we need to be talking to Cameron, Clegg, or Miliband, or one of our other elected representatives who actually have the power to change the system. Even if this address to the queen is so good that she's converted to Quakerism and republicanism, there's bugger all she could really do to change the system. - Thirdly, the peace testimony is a really bad historical example. In 1661, the (comparatively) tolerant, progressive Commonwealth had just been replaced with a monarchy that was determined to secure the superiority of the Anglican church and crush religious Dissent. Provoked by an armed uprising by the Fifth Monarchists, after which the rebel leaders were executed, Quakers had good reason to fear for their lives and certainly their liberties. Indeed, Charles' government would go on to pass a whole host of laws, such as the Quaker Act, which deliberately targeted Quakers for refusing to swear oaths, and the Conventicle Act which outlawed non-Anglican religious assemblies of more than five people.
In this climate of understandable fear, the Quakers published the Declaration from the harmless and innocent people of God, called Quakers. This remarkable document explains why the king had nothing to fear from an armed insurrection by Quakers, because Quakers were committed to peace. It's a wonderful publication, and a defining part of early Quaker history, but what it most certainly is not is a loyal address. Nowhere in the document to the early Quakers promise loyalty to the crown; indeed, the whole point of the declaration is to say that the king has nothing to fear from Quakers because they won't use violence to overthrow the king, rather than because they are loyal subjects. In fact, the document talks of Quakers waiting for "the kingdoms of this world [to] become the kingdoms of the Lord"; they're hardly endorsing the existence of an earthly monarchy.
Even setting aside the implicit republicanism (or theocracism) of the declaration, the key fact is that it isn't a loyal address or even a pledge of cooperation; it's a statement that early Quakers felt was necessary to protect themselves and their faith from the oppression and persecution of the monarchy. The Declaration, if anything, is a reason for us not to cooperate with the monarchy; it should serve as a reminder of all that's wrong with the institution.
The Process of Suffering(s)
Finally, I'd like to touch upon the Quaker business method and its associated problems. Now, the QBM is a really great system, and in general, it provides really good results. But it is slow.
The communication that BYM received asking Quakers to give the loyal address was, I assume, received between December 2011 and February 2012. As more or less a routine matter, and more importantly as something which needed to be dealt with fairly urgently, it was referred to Meeting for Sufferings. (Meeting for Sufferings, for any non-Quakers reading this, is the body that deals with Quaker business through the year when Yearly Meeting is not in session; it is made up of representatives of Monthly Meetings and other bodies, and uses the Quaker business method. It meets several times a year; the most recent was February 2012, and before that, December 2011.)
Meeting for Sufferings approved the idea of sending the delegation, but didn't write the text of the address; this was to be drafted by MfS Arrangements Committee. It would then be automatically approved, as there won't be another MfS session before the address.
Groups like YFGM, who were asked to be part of the delegation, were presented with the invitation, but, again, did not have access to the full text of the document.
Now, I'll admit I don't know how MfS Arrangements Committee works, and I'd hope there will at least be some element of discernment in the drafting of the address, but it seems to me that the text should be at the very least approved by the bodies which are being asked to accept it, and have it represent them- and Quakers in general- in a public forum. I've already expressed my concern that it may not adequately reflect Quakers' commitment to political equality, and I know that I would be a lot happier about the matter if I knew that it did. In fact, I'm certain I'd be a lot happier about YFGM being asked to make a decision on the matter if we had known the contents of what we were signing up to.
It seems like the obvious solution here would be to have had at the very least a draft of the address prepared for MfS to consider when they met in February; of course, this raises problems of whoever drafted it having to preempt the decision of the Meeting, although I feel this would have been a worthy sacrifice if it meant that the address was certain to be acceptable to British Quakers as represented by MfS (and could have been presented, complete, when groups like YFGM had to consider the issue).
One final note: there's an interesting contrast between the MfS minute on the issue, which talks about offering a loyal address to the 'Queen', and the recent article in The Friend which talks about 'Elizabeth Windsor'; a much more Quakerly approach, in my eyes.
Conclusion
So there we have it. Firstly, engaging with the monarchy is, in principle, at odds with the Quaker testimony to Equality. Secondly, it cannot be justified as speaking truth to power, because the message is likely to be incomplete, will not address 'power'. And thirdly, the process of making the decision has been flawed, because of the limitations of the Quaker business method with regard to time.
Normally, I can accept the decisions of BYM/MfS, and the outcomes of Quaker decisions in general; half the time I agree with them, and the rest of the time I know that they truly reflect Quakerism or at least the beliefs of Quakers . But this time, from the moment I was moved to speak at YFGM up to the present, my conscience will not let me rest; this is a completely wrong decision, made worse by a lack of knowledge and insufficient consideration.
I congratulate you for reading this far; I really hope you will leave your own thoughts and opinions, and spread this article to anyone you think may be interested. Below are a few relevant articles and sources that I've used or drawn upon in writing this post.
http://www.quaker.org.uk/meeting-sufferings-minutes-february-2012 - Minute S/12/02/15
http://thefriend.org/article/meeting-for-sufferings-news-in-brief2/ - 'Queen to meet Quakers'
http://www.quaker.org.uk/files/Quaker-Peace-Testimony.pdf
http://www.quaker.org/minnfm/peace/A%20Declaration%20to%20Charles%20II%201660.htm
http://www.ekklesia.co.uk/node/15412
I agree with almost everything here, but sorry I can't agree with "engaging with the monarchy is, in principle, at odds with the Quaker testimony to Equality." Refusing to engage with something/one on the grounds that you are opposed to it is not Quakerism, it's Ostrichism.
ReplyDeleteI see where you're coming from on this, but engaging with the monarchy isn't going to achieve anything positive; the monarchy probably couldn't abolish itself if it tried. On the other hand, there are good reasons for Quakers to boycott it; its inherent inequality, its history of persecution, to name but two.
DeleteBut you do have a valid point, so let's pretend I said simply that the *institution* of the monarchy is at odds with the testimony to equality.
Two things:
ReplyDeleteThe Crown is not supported by the taxpayer. The UK government receives far more from the Crown Estates than it pays out in the Civil List. As to whether money should be received from the occupation of land, that is another question. Most people pay rent of some sort to the owner of the land on which they live/trade. If it wasn't the Monarch, it would be the local authority or other commercial body.
Secondly, I object to your use of the term "bugger". The use of foul language is to be deprecated. If you demean your position by the use of bad language, it detracts from your argument.
Regards
Geoff Theasby
Firstly, the revenues from the Crown Estates are revenues that rightly belong to the country; for historic and symbolic reasons they are vested in the Crown. However, the Crown is a entity quite separate from the monarch, and the monarch and her family are supported by the taxpayer.
DeleteSecondly, I didn't use the term "bugger"- I used the term "bugger all". The former is a swearword, with historically negative connotations, which can be used as an insult and would, indeed, be a weak point in a serious argument.
The latter, however, is a colloquialism meaning 'nothing whatsoever'. It's not an insult, or meant to be insulting, and to criticise its use is as daft as censoring a pantomime about "Dick Whittington"
"The argument that got used in this context is that since speaking truth to power is a good thing, and a valuable part of Quakerism, and we've given addresses to the monarchy with that intention before, then taking part this time has to be a good thing. "
ReplyDeleteI don't believe anyone expressed that opinion, but rather suggested that as the decision to address the Queen has already been made by BYM, we should engage with that decision. No-one at YFGM was addressing the question of whether we should address the Queen, only whether we should suggest two people to BYM to send to address the Queen.
The fact that the address will be made in a public and no doubt media heavy occasion means that it is an opportunity not only to address the monarchy but also the country and its civil leaders and as such a superb opportunity to speak truth to power. If you believe our elected leaders are democratic then perhaps you will understand that they take much more notice of what is being said through the media than they ever will from what is being said by the public in churches and meeting houses. Any such opportunity is one that should be taken in my humble opinion.
ReplyDeleteI've only just heard that Quakers did this. I find it very hard to understand how and why we would take part in such a thing. I have no idea what Meeting for Sufferings was thinking. And to use her title too. Very, very disappointed.
ReplyDeleteJustin